
Migraine is a common neurological disorder that occurs in approximately 12% of adults in western countries and can significantly impair the quality of life of the patients. 1,2) In Korea, 6.1% of the population suffers from migraine headaches at least once a year, and women roughly have three times higher incidence of migraine than men. It is most frequent in women aged 40-49 years and men aged 19-29 years. 3)
This neurological disorder has a broad range of severity and symptoms; it is a unilateral, pulsatile pain, and aggravated by routine physical activity. 4) In addition, migraine is accompanied by one or more additional symptoms such as nausea, vomiting, abdominal pain, dizziness, photophobia, and phonophobia. 4) According to the International Classification of Headache Disorders 3rd edition (ICHD-3), the two major subtypes of migraine are migraine without aura (MWoA) and migraine with aura (MWA),5) and they are not completely distinct and exclusive. 5)
Appropriate acute therapy for migraine headaches can abort migraine attacks and suitable preventive treatment can reduce migraine frequency, headache severity, and health care costs.6) Acute treatments of migraines include serotonin receptor agonists (triptans), ergot alkaloids, non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs), acetaminophen, and opioids. 7,8) The American Academy of Neurology (AAN) has published guidelines for preventing migraines in 2012. 9) The AAN guidelines recommend metoprolol, propranolol, timolol, valproic acid/valproate/divalproex, topiramate with strong evidence, and atenolol, nadolol, amitriptyline, venlafaxine with moderate evidence. 9)
The purpose of this study was to (1) examine the utilization of migraine preventive therapy in eligible patients, (2) determine the factors influencing the use of preventive therapy, and (3) assess the frequency of drugs prescribed for migraine-specific acute therapy and preventive therapy among Korean migraine patients.
We utilized the National Patient Sample data from the Health Insurance Review and Assessment Service in 2017 (HIRA-NPS-2017-0014). NPS data is health insurance claims data of almost 1 million patients and includes patients’ diagnosis, procedures, surgical history, medications, institutional information, etc. 10)
The patient’s diagnosis was identified using
Migraine patients with a
The
Based on the previous studies and clinical trials, we considered patients with more than four migraine days per month as candidates for preventive treatment. 4,12,13) To estimate each patient’s migraine days, the defined daily dose (DDD) was used. DDD is an average maintenance dose of a medication used by adults, which allows the drug used to be expressed in a standardized unit. 14) We estimated how many DDD of each migraine-specific medication was prescribed to a patient per month and summed them up. One DDD was regarded as one migraine day.
Migraine-specific acute therapies include almotriptan, frovatriptan, naratriptan, sumatriptan, zolmitriptan, and a combination of ergotamine and caffeine anhydrous (hereafter referred to as ergotamine). Medications that are approved for migraine prophylaxis in Korea include amitriptyline, flunarizine, nadolol, propranolol, topiramate, and valproic acid/valproate/divalproex (Appendix A). Furthermore, we classified each ingredient of the preventive therapy into the following drug classes: Amitriptyline was grouped under antidepressants, flunarizine under calcium channel blockers (CCB), nadolol and propranolol as beta-blockers, and topiramate and valproic acid/valproate/divalproex as anticonvulsants. If any preventive drug was prescribed at least once in 2017, then we considered preventive medicine was utilized.
We evaluated the prescription pattern of migraine-specific acute therapy and preventive therapy. In the case of usage of multiple medications by a patient, the drug that had the highest number of DDD per month was regarded as the main acute therapy or main preventive therapy. Similarly, we summed the number of DDD per month for drugs belonging to a drug class, and the class with the highest number was considered the main drug class.
Categorical variables of the patient's baseline characteristics were expressed in frequencies and percentages using frequency analysis. To determine the association between prophylactic prescription and explanatory factors in candidates for migraine preventive therapy, we performed a chi-square test and multiple logistic regression analysis. Explanatory factors include demographic factors such as age group, sex, and insurance type; and health factors such as migraine type, migraine frequency, and comorbidities. The Hosmer-Lemeshow test was performed to check the fit of this model. We used the R Statistical Software (version 4.0.0; R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria) to perform statistical analysis, and considered
The number of patients requiring migraine prophylaxis was estimated as 534. The characteristics of study subjects and migraine prophylactic drug utilization are summarized in Table 1. Patients aged 50 years or older were the most among the three age groups (41.6%). Female patients are almost 4 times more than male patients (79.8% vs 20.2%). Most patients (96.3%) were covered with NHI. Patients with MWoA was almost 5 times more than patients with MWA. For more than half of the patients, an appropriate migraine type was not assigned due to the limited code information. The most frequent comorbidity was dyslipidemia (36.9%), followed by osteoarthritis (30.0%), then depressive disorders (24.0%).
Of the 534 patients, 234 (43.8%) were prescribed preventive therapy at least once in 2017 (Table 1). Migraine preventive drug use decreased with the advanced age (
Table 2 presents the results of the multiple logistic regression analysis. Patients aged 50 years or older were less likely to use preventive drugs than those under 40 years of age (odds ratio [OR]=0.513; confidence interval [CI]=0.302-0.862). Among comorbidities, epilepsy was the most influencing factor (OR=7.326; CI=2.586-26.488). Patients with depressive disorders are more than 2 times likely to utilize migraine preventive therapy (OR=2.439; CI=1.567-3.827).
Table 3 presents the patterns of drugs prescribed for patients who have an indication for migraine prophylaxis. Sumatriptan was the most frequently prescribed medication as an acute treatment (29.0%), followed by ergotamine (27.3%), naratriptan (19.1%), almotriptan (10.1%), zolmitriptan (8.8%), and frovatriptan (5.6%).
The most commonly used preventive drugs were propranolol (35.0%), followed by flunarizine (32.5%), topiramate (13.7%), amitriptyline (12.8%), valproic acid/valproate/divalproex (3.8%), and nadolol (2.1%). When preventive therapies were classified by the drug class, beta-blockers were the most prescribed (37.2%), followed by CCB (32.5%), anticonvulsants (17.5%), and antidepressants (12.8%).
This study investigated the utilization of migraine preventive therapy in eligible patients, determined the factors influencing the use of preventive therapy, and analyzed the prescribing patterns of migraine-specific medications and preventive medications.
Patients requiring migraine prophylaxis therapy was about 10% of the migraine patients who had been prescribed acute therapy at least once (n=5,390). This figure is low compared to 38.8% of migraine patients who are eligible for migraine prophylaxis in the US.2) The claim data we used did not identify the use of over-the-counter (OTC) drugs when estimating migraine days with the monthly average number of DDD of acute therapy. Since a significant number of migraine sufferers (49%) use OTC pain medications,15) those who are candidates for migraine preventive treatment might have been underestimated in our study.
In this study, 43.8% of patients had been prescribed preventive therapy at least once in 2017, and the proportion was similar or higher than in other countries. A study in the US reported that about 39% of migraineurs had an indication for migraine prophylaxis, but only 32% of them received preventive therapy. 2) Caetano et al. found that among 77 patients who were eligible for prophylactic treatment, only 22% of them were on preventive treatment in Portugal. 16) We might have overestimated the preventive drug utilization rate since we considered a patient as a preventive drug user if he/she was prescribed the index drug at least once a year. Nevertheless, more than half of the patients had not received optimal preventive therapy in Korea.
One previous study found that women experienced more frequent migraine headaches, greater disability, and more frequent consultation with their physicians about their headaches. 17,18) The ratio of women to men in the population of candidates for migraine prophylaxis was 4:1, which differed in frequency by age groups. However, there was no significant relationship between sex and the use of preventive treatment in our study. Common comorbidities that occur with migraine and affect the treatment include depression, anxiety disorders, epilepsy, sleep disorders, stroke, and other pain disorders. 19) Among various comorbidities, the most frequent comorbid conditions according to the results of our study are dyslipidemia (36.9%), osteoarthritis (30.0%), depressive disorders (24.0%), and hypertension (22.1%).
Diamond et al. reported that female and elderly patients with migraine were more likely engaged with current or past utilization of preventive therapy. 15) On the other hand, there was no significant relationship between sex and prescription of preventive agents according to a Netherlands study. 20) We found that women received more preventive treatment, although it was not statistically significant, and preventive drug prescriptions decreased in older people aged over 50 years. This may be due to the high use of multiple medications by older patients and physicians might be concerned about adverse drug reactions, drug-drug interactions, or drug-disease interactions. 20,21)
Caetano et al. reported that patients with MWA had higher rates of migraine prophylaxis compared to the patients with MWoA. 16) However, our results showed the opposite trend. We were not able to draw any meaningful hypothesis from this finding since more than half of the patients were not assigned to any specific migraine subtype.
More preventive agents were prescribed in the presence of epilepsy and depressive disorder as comorbidities. This may be due to the fact that the approved migraine prophylaxis agents also have an indication of epilepsy or depression. 22) In particular, depression is associated with severe migraines, and frequent migraine headaches with high severity are linked to increased use of migraine prevention treatments in these conditions. 20,23)
Sumatriptan was the most frequently prescribed drug for acute treatment, followed by ergotamine. According to a study carried out in the US, sumatriptan was the most commonly used drug for acute treatment, followed by rizatriptan. 11) Meanwhile, Sheftell et al. found that the most frequently prescribed drug was sumatriptan, followed by zolmitriptan, and then rizatriptan. 24) In comparison, at the time of this research, rizatriptan was not available in Korea and thereby excluded from the analysis. Since we analyzed the frequency of prescriptions by considering the highest average number of DDD per month as the main acute therapy in each patient, the results may differ due to differences in the methodology between the studies.
According to the Canadian Headache Society guideline and the European Federation of Neurological Societies (EFNS) guideline, ergotamine is not recommended for acute migraine attacks because it has lower efficacy and greater risk of side effects than triptans. 25,26) However, ergotamine was the second most frequently used medication after sumatriptan in Korea. This is probably due to the cost advantage of ergotamine. Triptans were about 50 to 80 times more expensive than ergotamine at the time of this study.
The most commonly prescribed preventive medicine was propranolol, followed by flunarizine, and topiramate. In terms of drug classes, beta-blockers were the most commonly used ones. The most frequently prescribed preventive drug in a US study was topiramate. 11) Another study found that beta-blockers were the most frequently used preventive drug as well as the first choice of physicians followed by TCA, CCB, anticonvulsant (topiramate) in that order. 27)
According to the international guidelines of the WHO/EHF, beta-blockers, topiramate, flunarizine, sodium valproate, amitriptyline are effective for migraine prevention and are recommended for use as a first tier. 28) The results of our study suggest that the medications were used according to the guidelines. Hypertension is highly prevalent in Korea as well as worldwide. 29) The high prevalence of hypertension may be related to the frequent prescription of beta-blockers and CCB as migraine prophylactic medication. The choice of migraine preventive therapy should take into account not only the efficacy of the drug but also safety, tolerability, patient preferences, and comorbidities. 4,30)
There are several limitations to our study. First, we used insurance claim data, originally generated for reimbursement purposes. Considering that it is not collected for research purposes, diagnostic information may be inaccurate. For example, it is difficult to compare patients with aura and without aura because migraine-type was not accurately classified and many patients were assigned to “other migraines group”. Second, the claim data did not provide detailed clinical information of the patient such as migraine severity, exact migraine frequency, medication tolerability, and adverse drug reactions. In addition, socioeconomic characteristics such as economic status, education, or health behavior were not available. Third, since the migraine days per month were replaced by the monthly average number of DDDs of acute therapy, the exact migraine days experienced by the patient could not be determined. Furthermore, when counting the number of DDD, it could have been underestimated because OTC drugs were excluded from the analysis. Fourth, it was not known whether patients were prescribed these drugs to prevent migraines or to treat other comorbid conditions.
Despite these limitations, our study provides evidence that migraine prevention therapy is underutilized in Korea. We also identified influencing factors that could predict the use of migraine prevention medications and compared the pattern of drug prescriptions with other countries. Our findings warrant further research on a reason why patients who meet the criteria for migraine prophylaxis are not receiving adequate preventive therapy.
In conclusion, more than half of the eligible patients with migraine were not currently receiving prophylaxis. Positive factors affecting the use of migraine prophylaxis were epilepsy, and depressive disorders. The most commonly prescribed acute therapy for migraine relief was sumatriptan, and preventive therapy was propranolol.
We used HIRA-NPS-2017-0014 data from the Health Insurance Review and Assessment Service for this study, but the results have no connection with the Ministry of Health and Welfare or HIRA.
We declare no conflict of interests.
![]() |
![]() |